I recently had a conversation with a family friend about design "rules" (now that everyone has easy access to AI, I am finding more and more people referencing them). Anyway, I suggested that they should be considered more of "guidelines", because people with a talented design intuition break them all the time when it "feels right". The problem occurs when a person unskilled at design decides to break them as a short cut - things can go wrong FAST! (are any of you familiar with the IG account: "Please Hate These Things?". She shows very good examples of "broken rules gone wrong"!)
Here are some examples of a "rule" that was broken on a project, and why it works…
Mixing metal finishes is a great thing to do when done strategically (see my former post titled Metal Finish Finesse, which addresses how to do this successfully).
For the Hillside House Primary Vanity mirror in the left picture, we used a black metal frame, which works because even though the plumbing and hardware is satin nickel, there are plenty of other black accents.
In the instance of the Fairview House Powder on the right, the fabulous antique mirror pulls tones from the Sunset Cloud Onyx stone countertop, and the light fixture and faucet mimic and anchor one another, once again with tones from the Onyx.
Fairview House Den
Mixed large scale patterns – the Fairview House Den uses a monochromatic color scheme with one primary colorful departure via the art. This prevents the space from becoming visually confusing or cluttered.
Art that is not on a wall – I ran across these images from Kim Nielsen Design, and they demonstrate such a fun way to add interest in an unusual place. Especially if you have an art piece you love, but not a good wall for it.
So, I guess my bottom line message is – if you are trying to make design decisions, don’t worry too much about whether there is a “rule” for it, but check your gut (sorry AI – I am not recommending you for this!) – does your gut tell you it works? Or does it feel “wrong”? In most instances when a client says “You might not like this” – my main question is, “Do YOU like it?”, and if so – who cares if I think it’s right or wrong!? And if you really don’t trust your gut – get feedback from someone who does (for example - a talented designer). Most of the time if someone breaks a rule and it doesn’t work, it’s because they tried to force it or didn’t pay attention. It’s not because they loved it and therefore did it anyway.
So, good luck with this. Now go out there and break some rules with confidence (haha)!